The song was "Paul Newman Vs. The Demons," which I have since listened to ad nauseum. I'll put the video at the end of this post for any interested. The relevant lyrics, though, are these:
"Live through the past again/ How many times must I/ Live through the past again?/ No more/ Wait."
Something that bothered me for a long time was the fact that I still struggle with the same doubts and sins and selfishnesses that I did before I got serious at following Jesus. Shouldn't I be conquering things? Shouldn't I be better? It took a couple years of learning that following Jesus is a journey (which is why I like to say I follow Jesus rather than believe in Him or trust in Him--all are true, but I think "follow" captures the heart of this choice better than other verbs), and since it is a journey, there are ups and downs and backtracks and resting periods and painful climbs.
Put another way, I used to think life ought to be a straight line--always getting better, always going higher and closer to God.
This is one of those times when I've actually internalized a thing. I no longer freak out at my sinful habits and unhealthy coping mechanisms. Sure, I need to work on them, and I need to pray that God will heal me. But they don't matter. I actually believe that God has saved me, that Jesus's salvation covered me, and nothing I do affects how God feels about me. I'm safe, and I can't lose that. I can screw up my life here and now, and there are consequences for the things I do, but God has me, and He knows my failings, and He's okay with the fact that I'm not actually superhuman. The Holy Spirit is committed to walking with me through anything and everything.
Okay, I got a bit PASSIONATE there. I'm just really happy that somewhere along the way those ideas sank into my heart and I don't have to force myself to believe them--I just do.
So the point is this: instead of life being a line, I now think of it as a pulled-apart slinky. Loop after loop. There is direction, but it's not straight. It looks as though just as much time is spent going backwards as going forwards, but somehow at the end of it all, you're further along than you were at the beginning.
The Avett Brothers sing about living the past again, and I get that. God has consistently proven that He is trustworthy, but I still freak out about the future. God has consistently proven that His love is pure, but I still pursue cheap imitations. God has consistently proven that living selflessly is more fulfilling, but I still put myself above everyone else.
And that's okay. I'm going to repeat the past. And I'm going to learn. And God will change me, slowly, sometimes painfully, usually without me noticing. It's going to look really pathetic from the outside, I think, and that's okay. God knows me, and He loves me, past-repeater that I am.
(The whole song is really genius. Here are a few more lyrics that make me think of The Avett Brothers as prophets: "You may have to drag me away from my demons/ Kicking and screaming/ It's been so long now, I've been with them/ I don't know where they stop and I begin."